top of page

The Marriage Reference Point

1 day ago
6 min read

Why are we still defining people by “marital status”?

Many of us have answered this question so often that we may no longer think about it. Raise your hand if you’ve seen this section on any intake form:

Marital status (check one):

• Married

• Single

• Divorced

• Widowed

At the doctor's office. At the bank. On paperwork related to the workplace, and in places where the information may have little to do with why we are there. We check the box and move on.

But more often, I find myself wondering: Why are we still being asked to define ourselves this way?

I began thinking about this after I started checking “single” instead of “widowed” on forms. I had been married for many years. My husband died, and for a time, widowhood was an honest part of how I understood my life. Then, about a year and a half ago, I began to think differently about the words “till death do us part.” Those words meant exactly what they said. When I was married—I enjoyed every bit of it—but when I was no longer married, I slowly realized that the relationship to being married no longer existed. So, when asked, I began checking “single.”

It was a personal choice, but it led me to a much bigger question and broader observations.

Why does “marriage” remain the reference point we use to classify people: whether they have never married, are no longer married, or are married now?

A little history matters: how we got here

For much of America's early history, the law treated a married woman as someone whose legal identity was joined to her husband's—an inherited English common law rule known as coverture. Under this rule, a married woman had limited control over property, the money she earned, and legal decisions made in her own name.

However, this legal framework did not apply uniformly to all women at the time; rather, it coexisted alongside other powerful legal systems. Enslaved Black women, for instance, were denied the legal right to marry altogether and were legally classified as property rather than human beings under the chattel slavery system. At the same time, many Indigenous women belonged to nations with sophisticated property rights that differed fundamentally from English common law, while Mexican women in newly acquired territories navigated property traditions rooted in Spanish legal origins. Race, freedom, and geography fractured women’s legal experiences into wildly different realities.

This multi-layered legal history began to shift in the 1800s, as states gradually passed Married Women's Property Acts that gave some wives more control over their earnings. These changes were piecemeal, took decades to unfold, and did not automatically erase every deep-seated inequality. Ultimately, looking back at this era reminds us that early American marriage was far more than a personal relationship—it was a core legal and economic arrangement that strictly defined a woman's place in society.

The law has changed. Women's rights have expanded in important ways, although progress has never been even or permanent. Some hard-won protections remain contested, and some freedoms have been narrowed. The ways people live have changed, too.

But I wonder whether some of the ways we classify people have kept pace.


I am not suggesting that today's forms are merely a continuation of coverture. They are not the same thing. But history gives us reason to look more closely at the assumptions that have shaped our institutions.

Why do we ask?

The U.S. Census has collected information about marital status for generations. The Census Bureau says the information helps the government understand marriage trends, changing households, family needs, and programs involving taxes and benefits. The Bureau has even debated whether some of these questions should remain in its surveys.

So, I am not suggesting that the information has no value. But does its value in one setting make it necessary in every setting?

If a government program needs to know whether someone qualifies for a spouse's benefit, marital status may matter. If a form needs to know who lives in a home, who to contact in an emergency, or who is covered by insurance, those are important questions, too. But are they all the same question? I don't think so. That's where we must pause.

What is the purpose of asking? What decision will the answer help someone make? Is there another way to get the information without asking a person to choose a label that may not describe how they live? Sometimes the question itself deserves a closer look.

We accept more than we realize

I recently read an article about bathroom decorating. It suggested replacing the usual bathmat with a runner, using a desk pen or pencil holder instead of a traditional toothbrush holder, or raising the shower curtain to the ceiling for a different look.

It was a simple reminder that we often accept the usual arrangement simply because it is what we have always seen. We may never stop to ask whether another arrangement would work better.

And we do this not just in our homes. We grow used to the questions and categories, and we answer them simply because they are presented to us. Expected of us. Over time, we may not even notice the assumptions underlying them. Marriage is one of those familiar reference points.

“How we live” is not confined to checking a box

People build lives in many ways. Some have never married. Some have married more than once. Some are divorced. Some have lost a spouse. Some share a home and a life without marrying. Others live alone and are perfectly content. Some are currently married.

Some people want a partner. Some do not. Some are beginning again. Others are not beginning again at all. They are simply living. None of these lives needs to be measured against marriage to be understood.

And let’s be honest: these labels do not hit everyone the same way. Historically, a man’s legal and economic personhood existed independently of his marital status. A woman's did not. While the laws have evolved, the institutional habit of tracking women through their relationships to men remains an invisible, lingering weight. When we force a woman to define herself by an old relationship status just to open a bank account or see a doctor, we are quietly maintaining an outdated system of classification that she has already outgrown.

There's even more to consider here. I am not arguing against marriage. I am not suggesting that people should give up a tradition they value or that institutions should stop collecting information they truly need.

I am asking whether we have made marriage the starting point when, actually, the individual should be:

  • If a form needs to know who lives in my home, ask me who lives in my home.


  • If it needs to know who should be contacted in an emergency, ask me who I want contacted.

  • If it needs to know who is covered by a benefit, ask about the coverage.

  • And if my marital status is necessary for a legal or financial decision, explain why it is being requested.

Perhaps the answer is not always a better label. Perhaps it is a better question.

I keep coming back to this: What if we stopped treating marriage as the reference point and started treating the individual as the reference point? That would not diminish marriage. It would make room for the many ways people live, love, build families, and find meaning.

Perhaps the most important freedom we achieve isn't always the freedom to choose something different. Sometimes it's the freedom to recognize a choice in the first place. The next time you're asked to check that box, I wonder if you'll pause and consider the question behind it.

Join the Conversation

How are we rooted? Where does our rhythm in life take us, even when institutions or outdated habits work against us? How do we find renewal when we step into our own choices and decide when to say yes or no to what is expected of us?


Have you ever questioned the label on a form—or the reason you were asked to choose one? I’d love to hear your experiences.

Share your thoughts in the comments below, or subscribe to Field Notes to join our community as we question the usual arrangements in life, law, and culture.

Poco a poco. Adelante.

Comments


Embrace the journey.
Sign up to receive Field Notes

from the Evergreen Life

© 2026 Janine Sound Experience, LLC.
Janine Evergreen | The Evergreen Life is a registered brand of Janine Sound Experience, LLC. All written and audio content is the intellectual property of Janine Sound Experience, LLC.

bottom of page